Elaine’s Boutique Hotel in Cape May: Historic Charm, Live Music, and Walkable Downtown Location

When you hear the words Jersey Shore, you have an image that will not be compatible with the beauty and Victorian splendor that is Cape May, New Jersey.  Nestled between the Atlantic Ocean and Delaware Bay at the southern tip of this vacation playground, Cape May is a historic city with a small-town vibe.  It offers a perfect blend of Victorian elegance, pristine beaches, and outdoor adventures with plenty of activities to keep you entertained.

The main attraction of Elaine’s Boutique Hotel holds appeal for a romantic weekend, a girl’s getaway, or a solo travel destination. Located on Lafayette Street, this family-owned boutique hotel is within leisurely walking distance of downtown shopping, dining, and Cape May’s beaches. With live music evenings, an on-site pub, and complimentary beach gear, Elaine’s creates a full Cape May experience that goes beyond simply providing a place to sleep.

Prime Location Near Shopping, Dining, and Beaches

Centrally located at 513 Lafayette Street, Elaine’s Boutique Hotel places you just a ten-minute stroll from Cape May’s iconic beachfront and steps away from the shops and restaurants of Washington Street Mall.

Free private parking, located behind the hotel, is a major perk in a busy tourist destination where street parking can be scarce. Whether you’re heading to the beach, browsing local shops, or catching a performance at Cape May Stage right across the street, Elaine’s location lets you explore easily on foot.

Rooms with Character and Comfort

Elaine’s offers a variety of uniquely styled rooms that blend the charm of a historic building with modern conveniences. Guest rooms feature hardwood floors, antique furnishings, and modern amenities, as well as a variety of room configurations. Some rooms overlook the lively front porch, while others offer quieter courtyard or parking lot views.

Rooms include flat-screen TVs, complimentary Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and renovated washrooms with contemporary fixtures. Due to the building’s historic nature, there are no elevators, and rooms are accessed only by stairs. It’s also worth noting that while many boutique hotels include breakfast in their room rates, Elaine’s does not. 

Phinney’s Pub: Live Music, Local Flavor, and Porch Vibes

One of the biggest draws at Elaine’s Boutique Hotel is Phinney’s Pub and Patio Bar. Inside, the cozy pub space features big screen TVs, an extensive bar, dark wood interiors, and a reclaimed tin siding. The real action happens outside on the expansive front porch. Guests can sip cocktails or local craft beer from the bar while relaxing in rocking chairs or cushioned seating areas.

Live music performances are a regular feature during spring, summer, and early fall. Bands typically perform on the lawn or porch stage, creating a festive but laid-back atmosphere that guests and locals alike can enjoy.

Other restaurant suggestions:

• Madison’s Bakery & Coffee Shop: Located on Beach Ave., this family-owned bakery has tempting treats and delicious donuts.
• Quincy’s Lobster Rolls: On Washington Street, this small takeout eatery had the best lobster rolls.
• Tisha’s Fine Dining: An extraordinary fine dining experience, do not overlook any seafood dish. Best feature: BYOB, bring your own bottle of wine!
  

Unique Features – Know Before You Go

Elaine’s offers thoughtful amenities that help it stand out among Cape May’s many boutique hotels. An on-site boutique sells beachwear, jewelry, and souvenirs with a Cape May flair. Guests heading to the nearby beach will appreciate the complimentary chairs and towels available for loan.

• Parking: Complimentary private parking is available behind the hotel, but spaces can be limited. 
• Accessibility: No elevators; stairs are required to reach guest rooms. 
• Breakfast: Breakfast is not included in the room rate but is available; also, nearby cafes and bakeries are walkable. 
• Noise: Rooms overlooking the porch and patio area may experience some noise from live music events.  
• Seasonality: Live music and dining at Phinney’s Pub are primarily offered during the spring through early fall. 
• Pets: The hotel does NOT allow pets. 

Room Rates and Reservations

Room rates at Elaine’s Boutique Hotel range from approximately $175 to $350 per night, depending on seasonality and room type. Peak summer weekends and holidays typically command higher rates.

For reservations or more information about seasonal events, visit Elaine’s Boutique Hotel’s website or contact the hotel directly.

Check rates online at Booking.com.

Final Thoughts: Why Stay at Elaine’s Boutique Hotel?

Elaine’s Boutique Hotel blends the best of Cape May’s old-world charm with a fun, social atmosphere that invites you to linger. It captures the spirit of Cape May—with porch living, live entertainment, and easy access to downtown—Elaine’s Boutique Hotel delivers. It’s lively without being loud, historic without feeling stuffy, and central without the hassle of street parking.

This property is very popular during the summer months, so plan ahead and be ready to soak up the atmosphere, whether from a rocking chair on the porch or a seat at Phinney’s Pub.  Elaine’s is a Cape May experience all its own.

Other Points of Interest in the Area

• Cape May Point State Park is free to the public and is an ideal location for birding, picnics, photography, and nature walks.
• Cape May County Park and Zoo – Delightful and a great way to spend the day with the animals. Located about 20 minutes from the hotel.
• Step back in time with a visit to the Emlen Physick Estate, a stunning Victorian mansion. Take a guided tour and learn more about this beautifully preserved mansion.  
• Embark on an unforgettable 2-hour sunset cruise with Cape May Whale Watcher – see all of the Jersey Shore from the Atlantic.